TIP 185: Null Handling

Bounty program for improvements to Tcl and certain Tcl packages.
Tcl 2017 Conference, Houston/TX, US, Oct 16-20
Send your abstracts to tclconference@googlegroups.com
by Aug 21.
Tcl-Version:	8.6
Author:		John H. Harris <JHHarris@valley.net>
Created:	08-Apr-2004
Type:		Project
State:		Rejected
Vote:		Done
Keywords:	Tcl, absent value


Tcl lacks the ability to handle nulls, data with missing or unknown values. In this TIP I suggest a means for representing and propagating nulls, and command modifications for manipulating them.


Tcl deals with strings, the universal medium for representing data. It lacks, however, the intrinsic ability to represent missing data, or nulls. A null datum (or just "null") is very different from an empty string. A database may represent Prince's last name as "" -- his name is know and it is an empty string, but if a respondent forgets to give his weight on a questionnaire, he is not weightless; his weight is not ""; it is unknown, or null. Nulls are common in real-world data, particularly data obtained from interviews or questionnaires. Because of this, most modern database engines and statistics tools recognize nulls. A large fraction of the applications we are writing are client programs to such databases, though the user is not always aware of it.

The programmer can use whatever is provided with the database application program interface (API) he is using, but most Tcl APIs provide none, probably because Tcl itself lacks nulls.

A Tcl programmer writing an interface to a database must improvise something to deal with nulls. If the data representation domain does not include an empty string, as for an integer or date, then an empty string may suffice, but arbitrary-string data is common, so something fancier is often needed.

For example, here is an approach I used in a current project built on SQLite [1]. I prepend each nonnull string with an apostrophe. Thus, nulls are universally represented by an empty string. I accomplish this using the coalesce() function provided by SQLite, e.g., if I want

  select id, name from persons

I must ask for

  select id, coalesce(''||name,'') as name from persons

I wrote a layer that automates this ugly mess. To keep it simple (and because SQLite is untyped) it prepends all fields with an apostrophe, even ones that do not need it. I deal with the apostrophes later -- testing for nullness is easy, but the apostrophe gets in the way for most other I/O and processing.

This is more than you wanted to know about my personal problems, but you can be sure this kind of thing is happening over and over with hundreds of programmers and applications.

Now let us imagine how it might be simplified, assuming Tcl null support and a revamped SQLite API:

  set result [ db eval {select id, name from person}
  foreach -null <unknown> { id name } $result {
     puts "$id: $name" }

I will explain more later, but basically, the database returns null information on every query, so there is no fancy SQL code. The -null option tells foreach how to represent a null when it assigns id and name.


It would be nice if null handling could be added to, or with, a single command suite. If we could just extend, say, the dict command, these objects would be ideal media for database APIs. Unfortunately, it seems impossible to implement any change with out involving Tcl's string implementation, list syntax, and command interpreter.

Representing Nulls

Not all commands will understand nulls. We will speak of null-smart and null-dumb commands. All commands follow these rules:

  1. Nulls represent a lack of information.

  2. An empty string is not null.

  3. Nulls can not be made "unnull", merely by being processed. This is equivalent to creating information out of thin air. Substituting a nonnull value for a null must programmed explicitly.

  4. For null-smart commands, nulls propagate. A null combined with any nonnull is null. Appending a null to a string, or substituting a null into a string nulls the entire string.

  5. Logical comparisons with nulls with respect to magnitude or identity evaluate to null (i.e., unknown).

  6. Null-dumb commands must treat nulls as empty strings.

Strings Objects

An empty string is not a null. We have the further constraint that we must be able to handle any arbitrary binary string, including null (in the sense of 0x00) bytes. Clearly the implementation must be augmented; we must add a null flag. In implementation, null strings would probably have their string part set to an empty string, to accommodate null-dumb commands, as in rule 6 above. Thus, dumb commands can simply ignore the null flag.

List Syntax

It is easy to add a null flag to the string class. To be of any use, however, we need to pass a null string to commands, which means embedding nulls in lists. We can indicate this much in the same way the {expand}{} syntax [157] works, by exploiting otherwise illegal list syntax. I propose using {null}! as null representation for lists. (Perhaps new syntax could be a rider on the {expand}{} rule. I fear that increasing the number of rules could scuttle this TIP.) At present this syntax (like {expand}{}) produces an "extra characters after close-brace" error.

Note that the string "{null}!" is not interpreted as a null string, instead it is a nonnull string that is also a well-formed list with one null element.

Interpreter Behavior

If the command interpreter encounters the word "{null}!" in a list, this element is replaced by a null string in the array of strings passed to the command.

When the Tcl command interpreter encounters a word that contains a variable substitution, if the variable contains a null, the interpreter will behave as if the entire word were replaced with "{null}!", and pass a null string to the command in its place.

Command substitutions behave the same way when a command returns a null.

Manipulating Nulls

We need not be decided how commands should respond to nulls all at once. Indeed, it would be better to let this evolve as we gain experience with this new dimension of data. At first we will need at least some basic support to create, copy and test nulls.

The String Command

The simplest approach is simply to test for nullness. The obvious candidate for this test would be an addition to the string is command suite:

  if { [ string is null $s ] } {
     error {Missing data for s.} }

The string command could also be used to generate nulls:

  set null [ string null ]

The Set Command

We can use set to create a variable that contains a null string:

   % set s {null}!

Now s exists and has its null flag set. This is such a natural syntax that it probably make string null unnecessary.

We can retrieve a null value with set -- suppose puts is dumb and sees the null as an empty string:

  % puts "s equals [ set s ]"

Set returns a null. In this case, the null is in a command substitution, and it nulls the entire string being passed to puts, which, being null-dumb, outputs an empty string and newline. This may be unsatisfactory. We would rather substitute a nonnull, perhaps an empty string, or "".

When and what to substitute is an ad hoc programming choice, so should be an option. Here is the set command with an option that tells how to represent a null:

  % set s {null}!
  % set -null <NULL> s
  % set -null huh? s

The default value for this option is a null, so [set s] can be used as a direct substitution for $s, as you would expect.

While we must allow for the worst case of representing a null amidst the set of arbitrary binary strings, in practical data this seldom occurs. When it does, we must resort to an explicit test and conditional execution, but more often there is some gap in the domain of valid data that can be used to represent a null. We have already seen the example of using and empty string for a null integer or date. For other data types there are better choices. The programmer knows these gaps and can choose a string that fits in the gap and is also easily understood by humans or other software.

The -null option should have the same meaning when applied to any null-smart command: if the return value is a null, change it to the option value.

The set command can use a similar option to assign a null. This time the option -nullify tells what value, by exact match, should be replaced by a null.

  % set s NULL
  % set -nullify NULL t $s
  % puts '[ set -null Void t ]'

Notice that string s above is not a null, it is the string "NULL". The second command translates it to a true null, and the third translates it to "Void".

The -nullify option provides a way of assigning a null to a variable that is independent of list syntax:

  % set -nullify {} s {}

The -nullify option should have the same meaning when applied to any null-smart command: if an argument value is an exact match to the options value, change it to a null.

List Commands

Most smart commands can just test the null flag of their arguments and take appropriate action. A few commands, such as lindex, lset, join, and split must understand list null syntax. Consider the string:

  % set s {a {b0 {null}! b2} c}

This string represents a list whose second element is a list containing a null. We expect this behavior:

  % lindex -null ~ $s 1 1 
  % lset -nullify {} s 1 2 {}
  a {b0 {null}! {null}!} c
  % lindex -null NUL $s 1 2

Join creates a string from a list and must understand -null. Notice that the second command below returns null, by rule 4.

  % join -null void {a {null}!}
  a void
  % join {a {null}!}

Split creates a list from a string and must understand -nullify:

  % split {a {null}!}
  a {{null}!}
  % split -nullify NULL {a NULL}
  a {null}!

Expr and Control-flow Commands

Nulls can be tested using string is null, but testing occurs so often in practice that we need to have expr and the control commands behave properly, allowing three-valued logic -- true, false, and null. (In this context, a logic value of null is often called "unknown".) Expr should recognise the -null option. These examples illustrate typical three-valued logic tautologies:

  % set u {null}!
  % expr -null unk { $u }
  % expr -null unk { $u && 1 }
  % expr -null unk { $u && 0 }
  % expr -null unk { $u || 0 }
  % expr -null unk { $u == $u }
  % expr -null unk { $u != 1 }
  % expr -null unk { $u eq {} }
  % expr -null unk { $u > 0 }

Notice that, logic expressions containing nulls may may have nonnull results. This my seem like a violation of rule 5, but actually is is just a special kind of lazy logic. Expr can simply ignore the null term because it is tautologously irrelevant.

The control commands if, while, and for all throw errors if the expression evaluates to null.

We can also use nulls to represent undefined mathematical results, or NaNs (not a number), in the terminology of IEEE 754 floating point arithmetic [2]. This allows Tcl to give the programmer access to hardware features that are currently hidden. To do this we need a -nocomplain option:

  % expr -nocomplain -null nan { log(-1) }

We can use the -null option to assign a usable value if a goes to zero:

  % set INF 1e16
  % set x [ expr -nocomplain -null $INF { 5 / $a } ]

Nulls can propagate sensibly through a computation and give a useful result when, without them, the same expression would have throw an exception. Again, suppose a goes to zero:

  % expr -nocomplain -null unk { $x / $a > 0.54 || $c < 0.042 }

Other Basic Commands

We need not make all commands null-smart immediately. Old commands can treat nulls as empty strings and function as before. They may be less useful than they could be, but nothing need break, because old code contains nothing that would introduce nulls in the first place. It is up to the programmer who decides to use Tcl's null facility to be aware of which commands respond intelligently to nulls. Perhaps a greater danger is that, once nulls are introduced, evolving commands may break applications that use nulls. Because of this, it would be wise to choose the initial set of null-smart commands with care.

I propose modifying the following commands, if necessary, to respond to nulls appropriately: lset, foreach, format, the list commands, return, set, subst, string, switch. Except as noted below, this means recognizing the -null option.

Now let us discuss the modifications needed for these commands.

String command suite: Except for string is commands, all string subcommands should return null if any argument is null, simply because the commands are meaningless when applied to a null string.

> Note that a null string is not unequal to any given string.
  Batman may or may not be Bruce Wayne -- his identity is unknown.
  Similarly, two null strings are neither equal nor unequal to
  each other.  Batman may or may not be the same guy as the Lone

String is: Except for string is null, all string is subcommands return 0 with a null argument.

Switch: The switch command should recognize the -null option. Having a switch leg that matches null is easy to imagine:

  switch $s {
     a { do this }
     b { do that }
     {null}! { punt } }

> but by rule 5 it would never execute -- nothing matches a null.
  Instead, use **-null**:

  switch -null NULL $s {
     a { do this }
     b { do that }
     NULL { punt } }

> If you must match any other nonnull string separately from
  nulls, use **-glob** and catch the null with _default_:

  switch -glob -null NULL -- $s {
     a { do this }
     b { do that }
     * { any other nonnull }
     default { punt } }

Foreach: The Foreach command recognizes both -null and -nullify.

Format: The format command should understand the -null option.

The list commands: In general, all the list commands treat nulls as distinct elements. Nulls never disappear from a list. llength includes them in the count. Commands that convert lists to or from strings (lappend, lindex, linsert, list, lset, split, join) should understand the -null option. Those that stay in the list domain (concat, lrange) should not.

lsort: If a list contains a null it cannot be sorted -- lsort returns a null string. With the -null option, it can be sorted after substituting the -null option value.

Issues and Extensions

In this section we discuss design issues that are either debatable or not entirely resolved.



[1]: SQLite

[2]: IEEE Floating point

[3]: MySQL


This document has been placed in the public domain.